· Broad Ripple Badgers
· Butler Bobcats
· Canterbury Coyotes
· Greenbriar Grizzlies
· Kessler Knights
· Meridian Marauders
· Rocky Ripple Rattlers
· Tarkington Tigers
| Team Timeline | ||||
| Team | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 |
| Broad Ripple Badgers | 17-19 | 18-13 | 10-20 | |
| Butler Bobcats | 26-10 | 26-9 | 26-11 | 24-9 |
| Canterbury Coyotes | 10-20 | |||
| Greenbriar Grizzlies | 12-19 | |||
| Kessler Knights | 18-19 | 12-21 | 8-25 | 20-12 |
| Meridian Marauders | 14-19 | 12-19 | 10-21 | 20-18 |
| Rocky Ripple Rattlers | 22-14 | 11-19 | ||
| Tarkington Tigers | 11-21 | 17-16 | 17-17 | 23-16 |